
Three and a Half Torches (Out of Five)
You’ve never seen anything like Coraline.
The new animated adaptation of the popular children’s book by Neil Gaiman tells a story that is both daring and sophisticated: a girl bored with her distracted, busy parents discovers a secret door in her new house that leads to an alternate reality with a loving, doting “Other Mother” and kindly “Other Father.”
There’s just one problem. They have buttons in place of eyes. And to stay in this almost-perfect family unit, Coraline might have to make a few sacrifices–starting with the fact that she just might have to replace her own eyes with buttons.
Things just get weirder and creepier from there, until Coraline finds herself in the middle of a pre-pubescent retelling of the Faust story.
We’re definitely not in Kansas anymore–or the palace of talking utensils in Beauty and the Beast, or even the harsh post-Apocalyptic landscape of WALL-E.

The overall visual sensibility of the film is amazing, simultaneously both edgy and retro, reminiscent of the Tim Burton-produced trio of flawed stop-motion films, The Nightmare Before Christmas, James and the Giant Peach, and Corpse Bride–though Coraline is more successful as a whole than even the best of the three Burton projects (by far), Nightmare. (Henry Selick, the director of Coraline, also directed Nightmare and Peach.)
Meanwhile, the stop-motion animation in Coraline, presented in 3-D, is so seamless and complicated that I was convinced it was CGI until the movie was over, and I was able to look the film’s specs up online.
As for the characters, I especially loved the character of the all-knowing cat–a refreshing departure from endless (and totally unfair!) movie portrayals of cats as devious and prissy.
So what’s the problem? Why is Coraline only getting three and a half torches out of five?
Unfortunately, like all the Burton films, Coraline is thematically ambitious and visually sumptuous, but only partly successful as a story. In short, it seriously sags in the second act. Long sequences involving the eccentric characters who live near Coraline feel like padding and, although they too are often visually arresting, simply don’t work. A new character not in the book, Wyborn, who Coraline finds annoying really is annoying.
In addition, after a gripping, unsettling start, the movie’s creep-factor is suddenly dialed down–probably at the behest of some studio executive eager to accommodate the film’s would-be family audiences. But by riveting down the tension, the film seems to lose most of its momentum. Things pick up before a terrific ending, but ironically, the result is a film that seems so leisurely-paced in the middle that it’s almost impossible to imagine an actual child being fully engaged by it.
Which is a real shame. So much of this film is so original and so challenging that, had the unsuccessful plot elements been worked out, it probably would have qualified as a classic.
Interested in buying the children’s book or pre-ordering the DVD? Support TheTorchOnline.com by purchasing them through this link
.